|
Suggesting the world would be better off without religion
takes a certain courage. Rosamund Burton meets a fearless
seeker of the truth.
Imagine Jesus sitting in a Sydney cafe drinking a chai
latte, and it gives you some of an idea of my first
impressions on meeting Sankara Saranam. He has long
brown hair with a few wisps of grey and a beard, and
his loose fitting embroidered Indian style top adds
to his Christ-like appearance. Despite the waiter adding
three additional heaped teaspoons of chai mixture into
the teapot, followed by much stirring, Sankara still
finds his beverage "lacks guts".
But the man himself is certainly not someone who lacks
guts. He is the author of recently published "God
Without Religion: Questioning Centuries of Accepted
Truths", which, as the title make clear, challenges
all forms of religion. Sankara's basic premise is that
all are based on stories or beliefs rather than on truth,
due to those in power wanting to exercise and keep control.
Certainly in recent years, we are starting to see evidence
of how Christianity has been shaped by those in power.
For example, for two thousand years, Mary Magdalene
was portrayed as a prostitute. But since the discovery
of the Gnostic Gospels, she is increasingly likely to
be seen as someone who was on an equal footing with
the 12 disciples and, in all likelihood, the partner
of Jesus. But I wondered if there are the same inconsistencies
in other religions? "What about Tibetan Buddhism?"
I ask.
"The whole lama tradition was started by monasteries
in the 15th century," Sankara replies, "so
they could maintain control and power." Those same
control and power issues surrounding reincarnated lamas
are still occurring today, between Tibetan religious
leaders and the Chinese authorities. Never one to mind
ruffling feathers, Sankara suggests His Holiness the
Dalai Lama should be questioning the whole idea of reincarnation
in this day and age.
The idea of a world without religion to me is like
saying let's do away with history, because faith and
culture are so interlinked. Perhaps that's why so many
people today who are not active practitioners of a religion
are still likely to label themselves Catholic or Anglican
for example, or say they are Christian.
Sankara's own background is Jewish.
"The Jewish identity doesn't fall away,"
he claims. "It's deeply cultural. It took me less
time to get rid of the Jewish religion than the Jewish
culture." Both Sankara's parents are Iraqi Jews
who were born in Baghdad. They were from wealthy and
respected families, who coexisted well with the Muslim
majority. But after World War Two, rifts opened between
Jews and Muslims, with many families migrating to the
new state of Israel. His mother's family actually migrated
to the United States, but his father's side settled
in Israel only to find themselves treated as second
class citizens because they were Middle Eastern rather
than European Jews.
"I learnt there was more divisiveness within religions
than between them," says Sankara. "You think
that sounds preposterous, but it isn't." He goes
on to explain that when he lived in Israel for a couple
of years in his late twenties he had no problem with
people of other faiths, but did experience antagonism
from Jews, because he was not adhering to the typical
Jewish dress code.
Sankara was born in America. He went to a Hebrew school
initially and then onto public school where he found
himself a target of anti-Semitism. Both his family's
and his own personal experiences, combined with his
natural inclination to question aspects not only of
Judaism but also of other religions, has led him to
seek a spiritual path that goes that beyond the narrow
confines of identity and faith.
Having excelled at science and maths at school, he
went to engineering school with the intention of becoming
a rocket scientist. Already diverging from that early
goal, he studied classical guitar before, at the age
of 23, entering a monastery in South Carolina founded
by Paramahansa Yogananda, who started the Self-Realisation
Fellowship.
Sankara had already been practising pranayama techniques
which have been used by yogis for thousands of years
to control the body and mind, but his practice was deepened
and strengthened during his four years at the monastery.
He then spent two years in Israel studying Hebrew mysticism,
and his first book, "Yoga and Judaism" revealed
that the Hebrew prophets practised yogic methods of
mysticism.
Returning to the US, he spent another two years studying
comparative religion at Columbia University in New York.
It was during this time that he founded the Pranayama
Institute, and posted on his website the pranayama techniques
he had learnt and been using over the years, to make
them freely available to anyone who wanted to learn
them.
"Prana" refers to nervous energy and "yama"
means control, explains Sankara. "Getting in touch
with the motion of prana in the body and brain helps
us to better understand our existence, while controlling
this motion by directing awareness inward can unite
humanity in the shared experience of God by expanding
the sense of self."
By the time he had finished his masters degree, he
had developed a similar opinion about academia as he
had about religion. He saw it as creating narrow identities
and defending theories, rather than a quest for true
knowledge. "It's about accreditation, not education,"
Sankara asserts.
In 1998, Sankara and his wife moved to New Mexico.
She worked for the District Attorney's Office and took
care of their day-to-day affairs, while for the next
seven years Sankara devoted his time to study.
He posted over 5,000 pages of his findings on his website
and received responses from people in over 70 countries.
It is this interaction that forms the basis of "God
Without Religion".
Originally, Sankara published the book himself, but
it has subsequently been picked up by publishers in
eight different countries, including India, Australia
and, recently, the United States.
The book includes 17 techniques for the reader to discover
and define God on their own, rather than accepting the
interpretation of a particular religious doctrine. Methods
include forming or joining a colloquium of people interested
in spiritual matters, and asking questions and discussing
issues. He also recommends the use of affirmations,
what he calls "commonsense asceticism" which
is the moderation of food, speech and sex, and pranayama
techniques.
As he talks, it becomes apparent that it is not only
religions that Sankara regards as holding power and
control. It is also large corporations. In typical fearless
style, he has set his sights on pharmaceutical companies
as modern day "evils", closely followed by
the petroleum giants. The decentralisation of power,
he says, is central to his philosophy and his wife and
he live with their two children on a 240 hectare property,
where they rely on solar power and practise holistic
land management and permaculture.
Sankara's strong views extend beyond religion and philosophy
into the everyday realm of television - according to
him, we should simply stop watching it. He also feels
that women's power is taken from them, particularly
in the Third World, by having too many babies. He looks
at the impact of this, not only in terms of gender inequality,
but also the detrimental effect that an ever increasing
human population is likely to have on human beings and
the planet as a whole. He believes that women are, in
most instances, higher custodians of spiritual values
than men, and has come up with the idea that women should
be given the choice to undergo voluntary sterilisation
in exchange for money, education, job security and priority
when it comes to adoption. This is certainly a controversial
idea and not one with which I personally agree. But
he is adamant that this would not only help empower
women, especially in countries where they are not on
an equal footing with men, but would also help combat
overpopulation.
"It's hard for women to sacrifice," he says,
"but somebody has to sacrifice. If we are not willing
to sacrifice, then what is going to happen? At least
try to have them later in life, after 25, and extend
the length of the generations. Also, we need to support
policies that will enable the development of women in
societies."
Certainly in Australia I think many people are questioning
religion and looking for valid spiritual alternatives,
and Sankara's book is a significant publication for
anyone seeking spirituality without faith.
The author constantly emphasises the need to question.
Instead of seeking to provide answers about God as organised
religions do, he encourages people to explore their
ideas of God by asking questions which he believes will
ultimately expand their sense of identity. He calls
this "an expanded sense of self" which, he
says, "can expand to include all of humanity, regardless
of nationality, beliefs, ethnicity, race, gender, or
lifestyle. If a suburban Midwesterner could identify
with an Iraqi farmer, a straight white southerner could
relate to a gay African American couple...we wouldn't
be able to propagate hatred and violence." In a
challenge to new age spirituality, Sankara claims people
are often only replacing one belief system with another,
and the result may be the same as blindly following
a strict religion. Too often, he says, new age spirituality
fails to be progressive because it discourages sincere
questioning.
Many prominent religious figures in the world today
are espousing tolerance of other faiths, and there is
increasing acceptance that the goal of God realisation
can take many forms. Sankara has gone a step further
and given people a path to experience God outside the
framework of any particular religion or belief. "God
Without Religion" will certainly have readers questioning
both the ideas and the author, but I believe thinking
along these lines is likely to become increasingly popular,
and it is exciting to contemplate the effect this will
have on spirituality throughout the world. And, such
questioning is exactly that this iconoclastic spiritual
thinker is seeking to encourage.
|