| Charlotte
Francis finds that animals know how to have fun.
It's been all things animal in my world lately: the
new wildlife documentary The White Planet with its frolicking
polar bears; watching a blue tongue lizard amuse and
confuse a cocker spaniel; and reading about the wonderfully
modest Sir David Attenborough, who shrugs off his skill
as a wildlife broadcaster extraordinaire by saying,
"I've got birds of paradise on my side. All you
have to do in my business is not stand in between them
and the camera." So it seemed a natural segue for
me to dip into Pleasurable Kingdom, Animals and the
nature of feeling good by Dr Jonathan Balcombe, a research
scientist based in Washington DC.
The premise of this highly accessible book is that
pleasure plays an important part in how animals experience
the world. In his foreword to the book, Peter Singer
(co-author of The Ethics of the Food We Eat) points
out that most studies in the animal movement have focused
on suffering and neglected to look at animals' capacity
for pleasure. Backed up with an impressive bibliography,
Pleasurable Kingdom argues that while animal behaviour
is influenced by evolution and survival, animals are
not necessarily responding consciously to these influences.
In other words, animals may experience pleasure for
pleasure's sake.
In the absence of rigorous proof that pleasure is adaptive
and that feeling good steers animals towards behaviours
that promote survival, he presents a wealth of evidence
and the book is divided into themes such as play, food,
touch, sex, love and transcendent pleasures with a quote
introducing each chapter. One of my favourites is from
Joseph Wood Krutch: "Most robins seem terribly
glad to be eating worms."
The author challenges the idea that humans are the
chosen ones and cautions against comparing animal and
human intelligence levels. A Wilson's warbler couldn't
do a tax return, for example, but is a super navigator
migrating thousands of miles each spring to return to
a patch of woodland it nested in the year before. And
for anyone who believes sheep are stupid, think again!
Sheep can recognise 50 or more members of their flock
from photographs of their faces. Even more impressive,
sheep have been seen to solve the problem of an eight
foot wide, hoof-proof cattle grid by rolling over it.
Some forms of sensory intelligence in the animal kingdom
go beyond the human experience: the ability to see ultraviolet
light, to hear at higher or lower frequencies and sensitivity
to smells and tastes we cannot detect. The nose of the
star-nosed mole is so well served with tiny nerves that
600 could fit on the head of a pin. Could such creatures
be capable of greater pleasure than humans? Statistics
also point to impressive social cohesion, and a lower
"divorce" rate, in some animal societies -
90 per cent of bird species are believed to be monogamous
and half mate for life.
There are similarities between man and beast too; all
vertebrates share the same physical structure as humans
and have five senses. MRI scans show animals experience
similar emotions to ours and evidence suggests that
animals with a backbone experience pain. Animals appear
to dream, anticipate the future and plan ahead.
The author clearly has a close bond with animals and
is the proud owner of pet rats, Rachel, Veronica and
Lucy. In the chapter on food, he demonstrates that,
given a chance, rats shun the fruit bowl and head for
the donuts, or Balcombe's freshly baked peanut butter
cookies. Rats also enjoy a good game of hide and seek
and the sensation of being tickled.
The chapter on play and thrill seeking is particularly
engaging. We are all familiar with the antics of cats
and dogs, but perhaps less familiar with the idea of
penguins, otters and bears tobogganing, dolphins surfing,
elephants trunk-wrestling, ravens flying upside down,
gorillas playing with labradors and red-neck wallabies
playing tag with magpies. While play helps in the search
for food and development of physical strength, it seems
that animals also play for the heck of it. Animals playing
in waves or water are often seen going back for another
"go" and octopuses, turtles and reptiles climb
up slides to repeat the pleasure of going down again.
In similar vein, anecdotal evidence suggests that birds
enjoy flight for the sake of it and also sing purely
for pleasure.
Balcombe advises that the chapter on sex is not for
the faint-hearted. He gives us a tour of the salacious
shenanigans of the animal king - and queendom, explaining
that much sexual activity takes place outside the breeding
season, another example of animals seeking pleasure
that is unrelated to survival. From spinner dolphins
to swallows, quite a few animals seem to indulge in
orgies but it is the apes and chimps that have the most
colourful and, to put it politely, varied sex lives!
In summary, animals are neither priggish nor especially
shy.
On top of sexual abandon, animals, it appears, are
no strangers to alcohol and drugs. Birds such as waxwings
and robins in North America gorge on fermented fruits,
other birds "smoke bathe" on chimney tops
and goats are credited with having discovered coffee.
Abyssinian herders in the 10th century noticed their
flocks becoming frisky after nibbling the red berries.
As any animal lover knows, animals have an enormous
capacity for joy, love and loyalty. And it's not just
dogs that become overjoyed when reunited with their
owners. Merlin, an eight year old raven in the US, clung
to his owner's shoulder all day after a six month absence.
Many of us will know the famous story of Scottish dog
Greyfriars Bobby, who visited his master's tomb every
day for 14 years.
Parrots are fiercely loyal, too. American biologist
Joanna Burger adopted a parrot, Tiko. After five years,
Tiko demonstrated extreme jealousy when Joanna nursed
an injured hen. But when Joanna was ill, Tiko laid out
her hair strand by strand in a fan shape on the bed
covers, rather like a mother brushing her daughter's
hair. When Joanna recovered, Tiko performed a celebratory
slide down the banister!
With tales of parrot love, pigeons differentiating
the paintings of Monet from those of Picasso, chimpanzees
marvelling at the sunset and fish enjoying their food,
this book not only delights, but on a more serious note
also raises ethical and moral questions about how we
treat animals. Pleasurable Kingdom highlights our human
responsibilities to animals as social beings with a
wide range of emotions and feelings.
Pleasurable Kingdom, Animals and the nature of feeling
good by Dr Jonathan Balcombe is published by Macmillan.
RRP $29.95
|